The inspection phase is one of the most important — and emotionally charged — parts of buying a home in Indianapolis. It’s the moment where excitement meets reality: you finally see what’s actually going on behind the walls, under the roof, and inside those older Indy systems.

But here’s the good news: inspection findings don’t have to derail your deal. With the right strategy, you can negotiate repairs, credits, or concessions that protect your budget while keeping your purchase moving forward.

This guide breaks down how repair negotiations work specifically for Indianapolis buyers, including what to ask for, what’s reasonable, and how to avoid common mistakes.

Why Inspection Negotiations Matter in Indianapolis

Indianapolis is full of older homes — 1920s bungalows, 1940s Cape Cods, 1950s ranches, and 1970s suburban builds. That means inspections often uncover issues like:

• Aging HVAC systems

• Outdated electrical

• Old sewer lines

• Foundation settling

• Roof nearing end-of-life

• Moisture in basements

• Drainage issues

These aren’t deal-breakers — they’re negotiation tools.

Understanding how to navigate them helps you make a smart purchase, not an expensive mistake.

Step 1: Understand the Goal of the Inspection

The inspection is not meant to create a “perfect home.”
It’s meant to reveal material defects — health, safety, or major system concerns.

Examples of reasonable asks:

• Roof leaks

• Active plumbing leaks

• Electrical hazards

• Structural issues

• HVAC not functioning

• Broken appliances

• Mold or moisture intrusion

• Safety/code concerns

Examples of not reasonable asks:

• Cosmetic issues

• Minor wear and tear

• Optional upgrades

• Perfectly functioning but older systems

A home can be old and still be a great buy — as long as major systems are safe and functional.

Step 2: Decide Whether You Want Repairs or Credits

Indianapolis buyers typically negotiate one of two ways:

Option A: Seller-Completed Repairs

Good when:

• Repairs require licensed contractors

• You want the issue resolved before move-in

• You need the home to pass appraisal/lender safety requirements

Downside:
You don’t control who does the work or the quality.

Option B: Repair Credit (or Price Reduction)

Good when:

• You want to choose your own contractors

• Work is extensive

• The seller can’t complete repairs in time

• You want flexibility

Downside:
You’ll need cash and contractors after closing.

Step 3: Prioritize What Matters

Not everything on the inspection report is worth negotiating.

Focus on:

1. Safety hazards

2. Systems near failure

3. Major roof or foundation issues

4. Water intrusion

5. Major plumbing or electrical defects

6. Anything required by your lender

Ignore:

• Scuffed floors

• Minor drywall cracks

• Cosmetic imperfections

• A system that’s old but functional

This makes your negotiation stronger and more reasonable.

Step 4: Use Quotes to Strengthen Your Request

A negotiation backed by contractor estimates is more persuasive than general concerns.

Examples:

• $3,200 sewer line repair

• $1,800 electrical panel upgrade

• $6,500 HVAC replacement

• $900 plumbing fix

Clear numbers = clear leverage.

Step 5: Know When to Be Flexible (and When Not To)

Be flexible when:

• The seller priced the home accordingly

• The market is highly competitive

• Repairs are minor

• Other buyers are circling

Be firm when:

• The issues are major safety or system concerns

• The home was priced as “updated”

• The seller dismissed known issues

• Repairs affect your ability to live in the home safely

Negotiation is a balance — stay reasonable but protect yourself.

Step 6: Avoid Emotional Reactions

It’s normal to feel overwhelmed when the inspection report arrives.
But remember: every home has issues.

Smart buyers separate:

• Fixable issues

• Normal aging

• True deal-breakers

Lean on your agent to interpret severity and strategy.

For more myth-busting clarity, see:
Home Buying Myths Indianapolis

Examples of Common Indy Repair Requests

Likely approved:

• Replacing broken GFCI outlets

• Fixing active plumbing leaks

• Repairing a non-functioning HVAC unit

• Sewer clean-out or camera inspection

• Treating mold or moisture

• Chipping and peeling paint on older homes (lead rules)

• Repairing roof leaks

Sometimes approved (context matters):

• Replacing an old water heater

• Panel upgrade for 60-amp service

• Minor foundation repairs

• Gutter replacement

• Exterior grading adjustments

Rarely approved:

• Replacing fully functional but aging systems

• Cosmetic repairs or upgrades

• Window replacement (if they still function)

• Optional improvements

What If the Seller Refuses Repairs?

You have options:

1. Ask for a credit instead

2. Renegotiate the purchase price

3. Proceed knowing it’s your responsibility

4. Cancel under the inspection contingency

Your decision depends on the severity of the issue and how much you love the home.

Pair with This Seasonal Guide

If you’re shopping in the fall or winter, repair negotiations can be even more important.
Use this alongside your timeline guide:
October Homebuyer Checklist Indianapolis 2025

FAQs: Inspection Repair Negotiations in Indianapolis

Do sellers have to make inspection repairs?
No — everything is negotiable unless required by the lender.

Can I ask for a price reduction instead of repairs?
Yes, and many buyers prefer this.

What if the home is being sold as-is?
You can still inspect — and still walk away if major issues appear.

How long do repair negotiations take?
Usually 24–72 hours once both sides begin discussions.

Final Thoughts

Inspection negotiations don’t have to be stressful. With a clear strategy, reasonable expectations, and the right agent guidance, you can protect your budget while still getting the home you love.

Indianapolis buyers face unique challenges because of the city’s older housing stock — but that also creates opportunities to negotiate meaningful repairs or credits.

If you’re preparing for inspection or need help evaluating repair requests, Roots Realty Co. is here to guide you through every step.

Buyer Resources: https://rootsrealty.co/buy/buyer-resources
Join our newsletter: https://rootsrealty.co/join-roots-newsletter