Why Indianapolis Is a Top Airbnb Market for 2025

If you're a real estate investor looking for consistent cash flow, affordable entry points, and a growing guest market, Indianapolis needs to be on your radar.

• The average nightly rate for STRs in Indy is ~$132

• Citywide occupancy hovers around 55% year-round

• New listings are up over 80% year-over-year

• Major events (Indy 500, Gen Con, Colts games) continue to drive periodic surges

Whether you're a private investor for real estate, part of an investors real estate trust, or just googling "home investors near me," Indy offers you an unbeatable combination: cash flow, appreciation, and growth-friendly regulation.

Know the Rules: STR Compliance in Indy

Since 2020, Indianapolis has required short-term rental properties to be registered.

• Permit Fee: $150 (one-time, per property)

• Renewal: Required annually, but free unless violations occur

• Minimum Stay: Two-night minimum required

• Violations: 3 violations = permit revoked

• State Law: House Bill 1035 protects homeowners' rights to operate STRs with some local regulation allowed

Bottom line: it’s not a free-for-all, but it’s extremely doable if you treat it like a real business.

What Makes a Great Airbnb Neighborhood in Indy

When evaluating where to buy, use these criteria:

The Top 5 Neighborhoods for Airbnb Investing in 2025

1. Downtown Indy

• High occupancy

• Top ADRs

• Proximity to conventions, Lucas Oil, nightlife

Watch for: Higher acquisition prices + guest expectations

2. Fountain Square / Bates-Hendricks

• Artsy, walkable, lower-cost fringe

• Near Mass Ave, cultural trail

• Great for duplexes or house-hacking

Watch for: Zoning limits on certain blocks

3. Riverside / Near West Side

• Proximity to 16 Tech, IU Health

• Lots of historic homes w/ rehab potential

• Lower price point = strong ROI

Watch for: Infrastructure gaps + safety variances

4. Little Flower / Near East

• Emerging, quirky, low price point

• Growing demand for local / unique stays

Watch for: Verify demand block by block

5. Speedway / West Side

• Huge event demand (Indy 500)

• Drive-up access

Watch for: Event-driven seasonality; off-peak planning required

The Data You Need to Know

• Avg Nightly Rate: ~$132

• Citywide Occupancy: ~55%

• Typical ROI Zones: Downtown, Riverside, Fountain Square

• Permit Cost: $150

• Violation Risk: 3 strikes = revoked permit

Want to dig deeper? Ask us for the full Airbnb Heat Map for Indy with permit overlays, revenue by zip code, and acquisition data.

Risk Factors to Watch

• Overpaying in hot zones (your ROI vanishes)

• Picking streets with low guest appeal (bad lighting, no parking)

• Assuming year-round occupancy (Indy has seasonality)

• Not accounting for city enforcement (permits, complaints)

Power Plays for 2025 Investors

• Go for duplexes or 3BR homes in transition areas

• Stage & brand like a boutique stay

• Use dynamic pricing software (Wheelhouse, PriceLabs)

• Work with local STR managers or cohosts

• Diversify across 2-3 neighborhoods to reduce risk

Looking to Go Deeper?

If you're serious about scaling your short-term rental strategy—or just starting your journey as a real estate investor in Indy—here are three must-reads to guide your next move:

• Out-of-State Investors: How to Buy Indianapolis Properties Remotely – Learn how investors from across the country are successfully managing and growing STR portfolios without living here.

• BRRRR in Indianapolis: How to Succeed with the 2025 Strategy – Explore how the BRRRR method (Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat) works perfectly alongside Airbnb investing.

• Indianapolis Ranked a Top 2025 Market: What Investors Should Know – Understand why national publications are naming Indy a breakout market—and what that means for STR and long-term playbooks.

These resources pair perfectly with your Airbnb investment strategy.

Final Take: Should You Buy Airbnb Properties in Indianapolis?

If you're an Indianapolis real estate investor or searching "real estate investors near me," this is your moment.

2025 is offering a rare combo: more listings, steady demand, and a city open to well-run short-term rentals.

Whether you’re local or investing from out of state, Roots Realty Co. can help you:

• Run the numbers on real deals

• Navigate permits and zoning

• Connect with STR lenders and managers

Ready to find your next cash-flowing property in Indy?

Explore Investor Tools →

Book a Strategy Call →