BRRRR in Indianapolis: Does the Strategy Still Work in 2025?

If you’ve spent any time in real estate investing circles, you’ve heard of the BRRRR strategy — Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat. It’s been a go-to playbook for Indianapolis investors for years because of our affordable home prices, strong rental demand, and solid cash flow.

But fast-forward to 2025: mortgage rates hover around 6.8–7%, and while rents are still climbing in Indy (up 6.2% year-over-year as of mid-2025), the math feels tighter than it did in the low-interest days of 2021. So the big question is: does BRRRR investing in Indianapolis still work in 2025?

The short answer: Yes, but you’ll need to be more strategic than ever.

What Is the BRRRR Strategy?

The BRRRR strategy is like the “house hack” of investment scaling. It lets you recycle the same pool of money into multiple properties without constantly needing new cash.

Here’s how it works:

Buy – Pick up a property (often distressed or undervalued).
Rehab – Renovate it to boost its value and appeal.
Rent – Place solid tenants and create consistent rental income.
Refinance – Pull out equity with a cash-out refinance.
Repeat – Use that equity to buy the next Indy rental property.

For Indianapolis investors, BRRRR has historically worked well because entry prices were low compared to rent potential. But with 2025’s higher interest rates and tighter lending, the margins are slimmer.

Market Factors Affecting BRRRR Investing in Indianapolis (2025)

Higher Interest Rates = Higher Monthly Payments

At 7%, a $150,000 mortgage costs about $300 more per month than it did in 2021 when rates were near 3%. That eats into cash flow quickly if you’re not careful with your purchase price and rehab budget.

Rising Rents Are Helping Offset Costs

Here’s the good news: Indy rents are still climbing. According to Zumper, the median rent for a 2-bedroom hit $1,280 in 2025, up from $1,200 just a year earlier. That’s a nice cushion for investors running the BRRRR play.

Appraisals Are Stricter

Lenders in 2025 are cautious, which means cash-out refinances aren’t as generous as they used to be. You may not pull out as much equity, so you need to buy right and keep renovations cost-effective.

Tips for Successful BRRRR Investing in Indianapolis (2025)

Target the Right Neighborhoods

Indy is still full of opportunity, but you can’t just BRRRR anywhere. Focus on up-and-coming neighborhoods where rents are rising faster than prices, like:

Riverside – Tons of rehab activity and close to 16 Tech.
Bean Creek – Affordable entry point with strong rental demand.
Haughville & Near West – Historically undervalued but showing growth.

Run the Numbers (Twice)

With higher rates, you need to be precise. A deal that looked good on a napkin sketch in 2021 could now break even at best. Use our Roots Investment Calculator to plug in rehab costs, projected rents, and financing terms before you commit.

Keep Rehab Costs Lean

Over-renovating is one of the biggest BRRRR killers. Stick to what tenants actually value: durable flooring, modern kitchens, fresh paint, and reliable systems. Skip the high-end finishes unless you’re targeting top-tier renters.

Build Relationships With Lenders

Local banks and credit unions in Indy often have more flexible BRRRR-friendly loan products than big national lenders. Having a strong relationship can make the refinance step smoother.

Does the BRRRR Strategy Still Work in Indianapolis?

The BRRRR strategy isn’t dead in 2025—it’s just evolved. Think of it less as a “get-rich-quick” play and more of a long-term wealth-building tool. The investors succeeding with BRRRR today are:

Buying below market value (often off-market deals).
Staying disciplined with rehab budgets.
Accepting slightly lower cash flow in exchange for long-term appreciation.

If you’re expecting 2020-level cash flow margins, you might be disappointed. But if you’re playing the long game, Indy is still a solid BRRRR market.

Q&A: BRRRR in Indianapolis

What’s the average home price in Indianapolis in 2025?
As of mid-2025, the median home price in Indy is around $235,000, up about 4% year-over-year.

How much rent can I expect for a rehabbed single-family rental?
Most updated 3-bedroom homes rent for $1,300–$1,600/month depending on the neighborhood.

Is refinancing harder in 2025?

Yes. With higher rates, lenders are conservative, and loan-to-value ratios are stricter. Expect to leave more equity in the deal than you would have in 2021.

Is BRRRR better than traditional buy-and-hold in Indy right now?

It depends on your goals. BRRRR helps you scale faster, but buy-and-hold with solid cash flow may feel safer in a higher-rate environment.

Conclusion: BRRRR in Indy Is Alive—But Not Easy

BRRRR investing in Indianapolis is still possible in 2025, but the math has changed. Higher rates and stricter lending mean you can’t rely on appreciation and refinancing alone—you need to buy smart, rehab wisely, and manage your numbers with precision.

The good news? Indy still offers affordable entry points, rising rents, and strong tenant demand. With the right strategy, BRRRR can absolutely work here—it just requires a sharper pencil and a longer-term mindset.

Ready to start your BRRRR journey in Indy? Connect with Roots Realty Co. and let’s find the deals that make the numbers work.

If you’ve spent any time in real estate investing circles, you’ve heard of the BRRRR strategy — Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat. It’s been a go-to playbook for Indianapolis investors for years because of our affordable home prices, strong rental demand, and solid cash flow.

But fast-forward to 2025: mortgage rates hover around 6.8–7%, and while rents are still climbing in Indy (up 6.2% year-over-year as of mid-2025), the math feels tighter than it did in the low-interest days of 2021. So the big question is: does BRRRR investing in Indianapolis still work in 2025?

The short answer: Yes, but you’ll need to be more strategic than ever.

What Is the BRRRR Strategy?

The BRRRR strategy is like the “house hack” of investment scaling. It lets you recycle the same pool of money into multiple properties without constantly needing new cash.

Here’s how it works:

Buy – Pick up a property (often distressed or undervalued).
Rehab – Renovate it to boost its value and appeal.
Rent – Place solid tenants and create consistent rental income.
Refinance – Pull out equity with a cash-out refinance.
Repeat – Use that equity to buy the next Indy rental property.

For Indianapolis investors, BRRRR has historically worked well because entry prices were low compared to rent potential. But with 2025’s higher interest rates and tighter lending, the margins are slimmer.

Market Factors Affecting BRRRR Investing in Indianapolis (2025)

Higher Interest Rates = Higher Monthly Payments

At 7%, a $150,000 mortgage costs about $300 more per month than it did in 2021 when rates were near 3%. That eats into cash flow quickly if you’re not careful with your purchase price and rehab budget.

Rising Rents Are Helping Offset Costs

Here’s the good news: Indy rents are still climbing. According to Zumper, the median rent for a 2-bedroom hit $1,280 in 2025, up from $1,200 just a year earlier. That’s a nice cushion for investors running the BRRRR play.

Appraisals Are Stricter

Lenders in 2025 are cautious, which means cash-out refinances aren’t as generous as they used to be. You may not pull out as much equity, so you need to buy right and keep renovations cost-effective.

Tips for Successful BRRRR Investing in Indianapolis (2025)

Target the Right Neighborhoods

Indy is still full of opportunity, but you can’t just BRRRR anywhere. Focus on up-and-coming neighborhoods where rents are rising faster than prices, like:

Riverside – Tons of rehab activity and close to 16 Tech.
Bean Creek – Affordable entry point with strong rental demand.
Haughville & Near West – Historically undervalued but showing growth.

Run the Numbers (Twice)

With higher rates, you need to be precise. A deal that looked good on a napkin sketch in 2021 could now break even at best. Use our Roots Investment Calculator to plug in rehab costs, projected rents, and financing terms before you commit.

Keep Rehab Costs Lean

Over-renovating is one of the biggest BRRRR killers. Stick to what tenants actually value: durable flooring, modern kitchens, fresh paint, and reliable systems. Skip the high-end finishes unless you’re targeting top-tier renters.

Build Relationships With Lenders

Local banks and credit unions in Indy often have more flexible BRRRR-friendly loan products than big national lenders. Having a strong relationship can make the refinance step smoother.

Does the BRRRR Strategy Still Work in Indianapolis?

The BRRRR strategy isn’t dead in 2025—it’s just evolved. Think of it less as a “get-rich-quick” play and more of a long-term wealth-building tool. The investors succeeding with BRRRR today are:

Buying below market value (often off-market deals).
Staying disciplined with rehab budgets.
Accepting slightly lower cash flow in exchange for long-term appreciation.

If you’re expecting 2020-level cash flow margins, you might be disappointed. But if you’re playing the long game, Indy is still a solid BRRRR market.

Q&A: BRRRR in Indianapolis

What’s the average home price in Indianapolis in 2025?
As of mid-2025, the median home price in Indy is around $235,000, up about 4% year-over-year.

How much rent can I expect for a rehabbed single-family rental?
Most updated 3-bedroom homes rent for $1,300–$1,600/month depending on the neighborhood.

Is refinancing harder in 2025?

Yes. With higher rates, lenders are conservative, and loan-to-value ratios are stricter. Expect to leave more equity in the deal than you would have in 2021.

Is BRRRR better than traditional buy-and-hold in Indy right now?

It depends on your goals. BRRRR helps you scale faster, but buy-and-hold with solid cash flow may feel safer in a higher-rate environment.

Conclusion: BRRRR in Indy Is Alive—But Not Easy

BRRRR investing in Indianapolis is still possible in 2025, but the math has changed. Higher rates and stricter lending mean you can’t rely on appreciation and refinancing alone—you need to buy smart, rehab wisely, and manage your numbers with precision.

The good news? Indy still offers affordable entry points, rising rents, and strong tenant demand. With the right strategy, BRRRR can absolutely work here—it just requires a sharper pencil and a longer-term mindset.

Ready to start your BRRRR journey in Indy? Connect with Roots Realty Co. and let’s find the deals that make the numbers work.

If you’ve spent any time in real estate investing circles, you’ve heard of the BRRRR strategy — Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat. It’s been a go-to playbook for Indianapolis investors for years because of our affordable home prices, strong rental demand, and solid cash flow.

But fast-forward to 2025: mortgage rates hover around 6.8–7%, and while rents are still climbing in Indy (up 6.2% year-over-year as of mid-2025), the math feels tighter than it did in the low-interest days of 2021. So the big question is: does BRRRR investing in Indianapolis still work in 2025?

The short answer: Yes, but you’ll need to be more strategic than ever.

What Is the BRRRR Strategy?

The BRRRR strategy is like the “house hack” of investment scaling. It lets you recycle the same pool of money into multiple properties without constantly needing new cash.

Here’s how it works:

Buy – Pick up a property (often distressed or undervalued).
Rehab – Renovate it to boost its value and appeal.
Rent – Place solid tenants and create consistent rental income.
Refinance – Pull out equity with a cash-out refinance.
Repeat – Use that equity to buy the next Indy rental property.

For Indianapolis investors, BRRRR has historically worked well because entry prices were low compared to rent potential. But with 2025’s higher interest rates and tighter lending, the margins are slimmer.

Market Factors Affecting BRRRR Investing in Indianapolis (2025)

Higher Interest Rates = Higher Monthly Payments

At 7%, a $150,000 mortgage costs about $300 more per month than it did in 2021 when rates were near 3%. That eats into cash flow quickly if you’re not careful with your purchase price and rehab budget.

Rising Rents Are Helping Offset Costs

Here’s the good news: Indy rents are still climbing. According to Zumper, the median rent for a 2-bedroom hit $1,280 in 2025, up from $1,200 just a year earlier. That’s a nice cushion for investors running the BRRRR play.

Appraisals Are Stricter

Lenders in 2025 are cautious, which means cash-out refinances aren’t as generous as they used to be. You may not pull out as much equity, so you need to buy right and keep renovations cost-effective.

Tips for Successful BRRRR Investing in Indianapolis (2025)

Target the Right Neighborhoods

Indy is still full of opportunity, but you can’t just BRRRR anywhere. Focus on up-and-coming neighborhoods where rents are rising faster than prices, like:

Riverside – Tons of rehab activity and close to 16 Tech.
Bean Creek – Affordable entry point with strong rental demand.
Haughville & Near West – Historically undervalued but showing growth.

Run the Numbers (Twice)

With higher rates, you need to be precise. A deal that looked good on a napkin sketch in 2021 could now break even at best. Use our Roots Investment Calculator to plug in rehab costs, projected rents, and financing terms before you commit.

Keep Rehab Costs Lean

Over-renovating is one of the biggest BRRRR killers. Stick to what tenants actually value: durable flooring, modern kitchens, fresh paint, and reliable systems. Skip the high-end finishes unless you’re targeting top-tier renters.

Build Relationships With Lenders

Local banks and credit unions in Indy often have more flexible BRRRR-friendly loan products than big national lenders. Having a strong relationship can make the refinance step smoother.

Does the BRRRR Strategy Still Work in Indianapolis?

The BRRRR strategy isn’t dead in 2025—it’s just evolved. Think of it less as a “get-rich-quick” play and more of a long-term wealth-building tool. The investors succeeding with BRRRR today are:

Buying below market value (often off-market deals).
Staying disciplined with rehab budgets.
Accepting slightly lower cash flow in exchange for long-term appreciation.

If you’re expecting 2020-level cash flow margins, you might be disappointed. But if you’re playing the long game, Indy is still a solid BRRRR market.

Q&A: BRRRR in Indianapolis

What’s the average home price in Indianapolis in 2025?
As of mid-2025, the median home price in Indy is around $235,000, up about 4% year-over-year.

How much rent can I expect for a rehabbed single-family rental?
Most updated 3-bedroom homes rent for $1,300–$1,600/month depending on the neighborhood.

Is refinancing harder in 2025?

Yes. With higher rates, lenders are conservative, and loan-to-value ratios are stricter. Expect to leave more equity in the deal than you would have in 2021.

Is BRRRR better than traditional buy-and-hold in Indy right now?

It depends on your goals. BRRRR helps you scale faster, but buy-and-hold with solid cash flow may feel safer in a higher-rate environment.

Conclusion: BRRRR in Indy Is Alive—But Not Easy

BRRRR investing in Indianapolis is still possible in 2025, but the math has changed. Higher rates and stricter lending mean you can’t rely on appreciation and refinancing alone—you need to buy smart, rehab wisely, and manage your numbers with precision.

The good news? Indy still offers affordable entry points, rising rents, and strong tenant demand. With the right strategy, BRRRR can absolutely work here—it just requires a sharper pencil and a longer-term mindset.

Ready to start your BRRRR journey in Indy? Connect with Roots Realty Co. and let’s find the deals that make the numbers work.

If you’ve spent any time in real estate investing circles, you’ve heard of the BRRRR strategy — Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat. It’s been a go-to playbook for Indianapolis investors for years because of our affordable home prices, strong rental demand, and solid cash flow.

But fast-forward to 2025: mortgage rates hover around 6.8–7%, and while rents are still climbing in Indy (up 6.2% year-over-year as of mid-2025), the math feels tighter than it did in the low-interest days of 2021. So the big question is: does BRRRR investing in Indianapolis still work in 2025?

The short answer: Yes, but you’ll need to be more strategic than ever.

What Is the BRRRR Strategy?

The BRRRR strategy is like the “house hack” of investment scaling. It lets you recycle the same pool of money into multiple properties without constantly needing new cash.

Here’s how it works:

Buy – Pick up a property (often distressed or undervalued).
Rehab – Renovate it to boost its value and appeal.
Rent – Place solid tenants and create consistent rental income.
Refinance – Pull out equity with a cash-out refinance.
Repeat – Use that equity to buy the next Indy rental property.

For Indianapolis investors, BRRRR has historically worked well because entry prices were low compared to rent potential. But with 2025’s higher interest rates and tighter lending, the margins are slimmer.

Market Factors Affecting BRRRR Investing in Indianapolis (2025)

Higher Interest Rates = Higher Monthly Payments

At 7%, a $150,000 mortgage costs about $300 more per month than it did in 2021 when rates were near 3%. That eats into cash flow quickly if you’re not careful with your purchase price and rehab budget.

Rising Rents Are Helping Offset Costs

Here’s the good news: Indy rents are still climbing. According to Zumper, the median rent for a 2-bedroom hit $1,280 in 2025, up from $1,200 just a year earlier. That’s a nice cushion for investors running the BRRRR play.

Appraisals Are Stricter

Lenders in 2025 are cautious, which means cash-out refinances aren’t as generous as they used to be. You may not pull out as much equity, so you need to buy right and keep renovations cost-effective.

Tips for Successful BRRRR Investing in Indianapolis (2025)

Target the Right Neighborhoods

Indy is still full of opportunity, but you can’t just BRRRR anywhere. Focus on up-and-coming neighborhoods where rents are rising faster than prices, like:

Riverside – Tons of rehab activity and close to 16 Tech.
Bean Creek – Affordable entry point with strong rental demand.
Haughville & Near West – Historically undervalued but showing growth.

Run the Numbers (Twice)

With higher rates, you need to be precise. A deal that looked good on a napkin sketch in 2021 could now break even at best. Use our Roots Investment Calculator to plug in rehab costs, projected rents, and financing terms before you commit.

Keep Rehab Costs Lean

Over-renovating is one of the biggest BRRRR killers. Stick to what tenants actually value: durable flooring, modern kitchens, fresh paint, and reliable systems. Skip the high-end finishes unless you’re targeting top-tier renters.

Build Relationships With Lenders

Local banks and credit unions in Indy often have more flexible BRRRR-friendly loan products than big national lenders. Having a strong relationship can make the refinance step smoother.

Does the BRRRR Strategy Still Work in Indianapolis?

The BRRRR strategy isn’t dead in 2025—it’s just evolved. Think of it less as a “get-rich-quick” play and more of a long-term wealth-building tool. The investors succeeding with BRRRR today are:

Buying below market value (often off-market deals).
Staying disciplined with rehab budgets.
Accepting slightly lower cash flow in exchange for long-term appreciation.

If you’re expecting 2020-level cash flow margins, you might be disappointed. But if you’re playing the long game, Indy is still a solid BRRRR market.

Q&A: BRRRR in Indianapolis

What’s the average home price in Indianapolis in 2025?
As of mid-2025, the median home price in Indy is around $235,000, up about 4% year-over-year.

How much rent can I expect for a rehabbed single-family rental?
Most updated 3-bedroom homes rent for $1,300–$1,600/month depending on the neighborhood.

Is refinancing harder in 2025?

Yes. With higher rates, lenders are conservative, and loan-to-value ratios are stricter. Expect to leave more equity in the deal than you would have in 2021.

Is BRRRR better than traditional buy-and-hold in Indy right now?

It depends on your goals. BRRRR helps you scale faster, but buy-and-hold with solid cash flow may feel safer in a higher-rate environment.

Conclusion: BRRRR in Indy Is Alive—But Not Easy

BRRRR investing in Indianapolis is still possible in 2025, but the math has changed. Higher rates and stricter lending mean you can’t rely on appreciation and refinancing alone—you need to buy smart, rehab wisely, and manage your numbers with precision.

The good news? Indy still offers affordable entry points, rising rents, and strong tenant demand. With the right strategy, BRRRR can absolutely work here—it just requires a sharper pencil and a longer-term mindset.

Ready to start your BRRRR journey in Indy? Connect with Roots Realty Co. and let’s find the deals that make the numbers work.

Find an Agent

Book a Consultation

Book a Consultation

Find an Agent

Book a Consultation

Book a Consultation