Buying your first home in Indianapolis is exciting — but the process can also feel overwhelming. With shifting interest rates, tight inventory in certain neighborhoods, and a flood of online opinions, it’s easy to stumble into costly mistakes that slow your search or shrink your buying power.

The good news? Most first-time buyer mistakes are completely avoidable with a little local insight and preparation.

Here are the five biggest mistakes first-time Indianapolis homebuyers make in 2025 — and how to avoid them.

Mistake #1: Waiting Too Long to Get Pre-Approved

Many first-time buyers start by browsing homes on Zillow or Realtor.com and fall in love with neighborhoods before talking to a lender.
But in today’s market, pre-approval isn’t the last step — it’s the first.

Why it matters in Indianapolis:

• Homes priced competitively still move quickly.

• A strong pre-approval helps you stand out against other buyers.

• You’ll understand your true monthly payment before you’re emotionally attached to a house.

Pre-approval also helps you compare loan programs (FHA, VA, conventional, down payment assistance) and understand which option best fits your financial picture.

For myth-busting on this topic, check out our related post:
Home Buying Myths Indianapolis First-Time Buyer

Mistake #2: Focusing Only on the House — Not the Neighborhood

First-time buyers often zero in on the home features: updated kitchen, open layout, yard size.
But the location plays a bigger role in long-term happiness and resale value.

When comparing Indianapolis neighborhoods, think about:

• Commute time

• Nearby parks, trails, and amenities

• School district (even if you don’t have kids)

• Future development and infrastructure plans

• Resale trends in the area

A beautifully renovated home in the wrong location is still the wrong home.

Mistake #3: Underestimating Total Monthly Costs

The sticker price is just the beginning.
Your monthly payment includes:

• Mortgage (principal + interest)

• Property taxes

• Homeowners insurance

• Mortgage insurance (if applicable)

• HOA fees (for condos/townhomes)

• Utilities

Many first-time buyers are surprised by the full monthly number — especially with rising insurance premiums and updated tax assessments across Marion County.

To avoid surprises:

• Ask your lender for a detailed payment breakdown.

• Review recent tax records on the property.

• Factor in utility averages if buying an older home.

Knowledge is power, especially when stretching for that first home.

Mistake #4: Skipping the Inspection (or Not Taking It Seriously)

In competitive markets, buyers sometimes consider skipping inspections to make their offer stronger.
But in Indianapolis — a city with older housing stock — this is almost always a bad idea.

Inspections reveal:

• Aging roofs

• Electrical issues

• Foundation concerns

• Sump pump failures

• Plumbing problems

• Mold or moisture issues

• Outdated HVAC systems

These aren’t minor fixes. They’re expensive.
An inspection gives you leverage for repairs or credits — and clarity on what you’re walking into.

Even if your offer is “as-is,” you should still inspect for your own protection.

Mistake #5: Assuming You Don’t Qualify for Down Payment Help

This is one of the biggest misconceptions among Indianapolis first-time buyers.

Most buyers dramatically overestimate how much they need for a down payment.

Some 2025 examples:

• FHA loans require as little as 3.5% down.

• Conventional loans can go as low as 3% down for first-time buyers.

• Many Indy buyers qualify for down payment assistance, closing cost grants, or below-market interest rate programs.

If you’re not sure where to start, our guide on local options is a must-read:
Indianapolis 2025 First-Time Homebuyer Programs

These programs can be the difference between “we’re not ready yet” and “we’re moving in next month.”

Bonus Mistake: Trying to Time the Market

First-time buyers often try to predict where rates or prices will go.
But here’s the truth:

You don’t win by timing the market — you win by time in the market.

If you find a home you love, can comfortably afford the payment, and plan to stay a while, that’s good timing.

How to Avoid These Mistakes

Here’s what successful first-time Indy buyers do differently:

• Get pre-approved before touring

• Shop neighborhoods as much as houses

• Understand the full monthly payment

• Treat inspections as non-negotiable

• Explore local financing and grant programs

• Take a long-term approach

You don’t have to navigate the process alone — and having a knowledgeable local agent dramatically lowers your risk of making costly mistakes.

FAQs for First-Time Buyers in Indy, 2025

How much should I save for a down payment?
Anywhere from 3–10% is common for first-time buyers, depending on the loan type.

How competitive is the Indianapolis housing market right now?
Certain neighborhoods and price points remain competitive, especially under $300K, but the overall pace has stabilized compared to 2021–2022.

Should I buy now or wait for rates to fall?
Rates may adjust, but waiting often costs buyers more due to rising prices. If the monthly payment works, it’s worth moving forward.

Do first-time buyers need perfect credit?
No. FHA programs allow for more flexibility, and many buyers qualify with mid-600s scores.

Final Thoughts

Buying your first home is a major milestone — and with the right preparation, it doesn’t have to be stressful. By avoiding these five common mistakes, you’ll shop smarter, negotiate stronger, and feel far more confident throughout the process.

If you’re ready to explore neighborhoods, compare loan programs, or start your Indianapolis home search, Roots Realty Co. is here to guide you every step of the way.

Buyer Resources: https://rootsrealty.co/buy/buyer-resources
Join our newsletter: https://rootsrealty.co/join-roots-newsletter