Build, Rent, Refinance, Repeat—Indy Style

The BRRRR method—Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat—has been a go-to strategy for real estate investors looking to scale. And in 2025, Indianapolis remains one of the best markets in the country to pull it off.

If you're ready to level up your portfolio, reduce cash outlay, and stack equity fast, this guide breaks down exactly how to BRRRR in Indy today—with local tips, market stats, and Roots Realty's investor-tested insights.

Why BRRRR Still Works in Indy in 2025

Indianapolis checks every box for a successful BRRRR market:

• Affordable entry prices (still below national median)

• Strong rental demand from transplants, students, and young professionals

• Plenty of distressed or undervalued properties to renovate

• Investor-friendly lending environment and property taxes

Average Home Price in Indy (2025): ~$260,000
Average Rent for 2BR: ~$1,350
Target BRRRR Price Point: $120K–$250K (pre-rehab)

The key is knowing where to buy and how to run the numbers—both areas where Roots agents specialize.

How the BRRRR Method Works (and Where People Mess It Up)

Let’s break down the 5 steps of BRRRR with Indy-specific context:

Buy

Look for distressed or underpriced properties—often foreclosures, off-market deals, or tired rentals.

Tips for buying right in Indy:

• Focus on neighborhoods with growth indicators: like Near Eastside, Garfield Park, Riverside, or Martindale-Brightwood

• Use Zenlist + off-market channels: Roots agents can plug you into exclusive inventory

• Set a reno budget upfront: Ask us for average rehab costs by neighborhood

Rehab

This is where you force equity. The right upgrades (not over-renovating) make or break the deal.

Investor-tested rehab upgrades in Indy:

• Replacing mechanicals (HVAC, plumbing, electrical)

• Refinishing hardwoods, painting, lighting

• Kitchen/bath refresh, not total gut unless needed

• Curb appeal: exterior paint, landscaping

Pro Tip: The goal is to raise the value enough for a strong refinance—but don’t overspend past neighborhood comps.

Rent

Once rehabbed, rent the unit to stabilize your asset. A great renter improves cash flow and helps with appraisal comps.

Key Indy rental tips:

• Invest near IUPUI, major hospitals, or Butler to tap into strong tenant pools

• Ask us for current rental comps and Section 8 options

• Consider 2BR/1BA units for widest demand

Roots clients often use our rental partner network (including T&H Realty and Liv Indy) to manage properties post-BRRRR.

Refinance

Time to pull your money back out. This is the trickiest part—especially with interest rates and appraisals fluctuating.

2025 BRRRR refinance keys:

• Work with a lender who understands investment refis

• Wait 6 months seasoning minimum for conventional cash-out

• Use the after-repair value (ARV) appraisal to unlock equity

• Make sure rental income is reflected on your lease + bank statements

Roots can help you connect with Indy lenders who specialize in BRRRR-friendly loans.

Repeat

Now that your capital is back, you reinvest it into the next property—and keep building.

House-hackers often graduate to BRRRR by turning a first duplex into leverage for their next deal.

Best Indy Neighborhoods for BRRRR in 2025

Looking for local targets that still cash flow after the rehab?

Here are some of the hottest BRRRR zones right now:

• Garfield Park: Artsy, still undervalued, great park access

• Near Eastside: Rapidly improving, lots of duplex/fourplex opportunities

• Martindale-Brightwood: On the radar but still below market comps

• Bates-Hendricks (fringe): Rehab-ready blocks just south of the square

• Riverside: New park investment and major momentum

Roots agents walk these neighborhoods regularly and know where the next deals are coming.

Common Mistakes New BRRRR Investors Make

We’ve seen what works—and what doesn’t. Here’s what to avoid:

1. Over-improving the property
Don’t put granite countertops in a $150K rental area.

2. Skipping the numbers
Use a realistic ARV and rental rate, not wishful thinking.

3. Choosing the wrong contractor
Ask for investor references—and keep tight oversight.

4. Not preparing for refinancing hurdles
Get pre-approved for your refinance before you buy.

5. Buying in the wrong neighborhood
Not all cheap homes = good BRRRR deals. Look for demand and growth.

Need a second set of eyes on your deal? Book a free BRRRR consult with Roots.

Q&A: BRRRR in Indianapolis

Is BRRRR still profitable in 2025?

Yes—if you buy right and renovate strategically. Indy offers solid cash flow and appreciation in key neighborhoods, even with rising rates.

How much cash do I need to start BRRRR?

Typically $40K–$70K depending on the deal. You’ll need funds for purchase, rehab, and holding costs before you refinance.

Can I BRRRR with a duplex or triplex?

Absolutely. In fact, multi-units are ideal for maximizing income and lowering vacancy risk.

What’s the average refi rate for investors in Indy?

As of late 2025, expect investor cash-out refi rates around 6.5%–7.5%, depending on credit and LTV.

Where can I find a BRRRR calculator or checklist?

Use our free tools on the Roots investor resources page (linked below) to estimate returns and stay organized.

Let’s Build Your BRRRR Blueprint

Ready to take action? Our Roots Realty Co. agents are also investors—we’ve done this, and we can help you do it too.

Whether you need your first deal breakdown, off-market leads, or lending partners, we’re here to be your Indy BRRRR team.

Explore Investor Tools →
Let’s Talk Strategy →