Tyler Lingle

Oct 28, 2025

Neighborhood Spotlight: Bates-Hendricks – Indy's Up-and-Coming Fixer-Upper Hotspot

Discover why Bates-Hendricks is a top Indianapolis real estate investment neighborhood in 2025. Learn ROI trends, rehab potential, and investor strategies.

Investors
Indy Neighborhoods

Once a quiet, overlooked pocket just south of downtown, Bates-Hendricks has exploded into one of Indianapolis’s hottest small-scale investment markets.

With proximity to Fountain Square and downtown, charming historic homes, and an active neighborhood association, this area has become a go-to for BRRRR investors, flippers, and first-time buyers looking for solid returns under $350K.

Here’s why Bates-Hendricks is on every investor’s radar in 2025 — and how to make the most of this fixer-upper-friendly neighborhood.

Bates-Hendricks at a Glance (2025)

Location: Just south of downtown Indianapolis, bordered by Madison Ave, East St, and I-70
Vibe: Historic charm meets new energy
Average home price: ~$295,000 (Redfin, Q3 2025)
Average rent: $1,500/month
Appreciation (past 5 years): +43%
Vacancy rate: ~5% (below city average)

In short: Bates-Hendricks offers downtown proximity, affordable buy-ins, and tons of rehab potential — a rare combo for Indy investors in 2025.

Why Investors Love Bates-Hendricks

1. Affordable Entry + Strong ROI

Homes here are priced well below nearby Fountain Square, but rent and resale numbers are quickly catching up.

  • Entry prices: $225K–$325K for renovated homes, $160K–$220K for fixer-uppers

  • Rent potential: $1,400–$1,800/month for 2–3 bedroom homes

  • Cap rates: 7–9% for turnkey rentals, up to 10%+ for rehabbed BRRRR projects

For investors priced out of Fountain Square or downtown, Bates-Hendricks offers real cash flow with upside appreciation.

2. Ongoing Neighborhood Revitalization

The Bates-Hendricks Neighborhood Association and local developers have been steadily revitalizing the area since the early 2010s.

Recent improvements include:

  • New sidewalks, parks, and public spaces

  • Restored historic homes and duplexes

  • Local businesses like Lincoln Lane Coffee and Two Chicks District Co. (made famous by HGTV’s Good Bones)

That visibility has drawn new homeowners and investors, pushing up both home values and rent demand.

3. Perfect for BRRRR and House Hacking

Bates-Hendricks is ideal for Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat (BRRRR) investors and house hackers who want to live in one side of a duplex while renting the other.

Typical strategy:

  1. Buy a dated single-family or duplex under $250K

  2. Invest $40K–$60K in updates (kitchen, bath, mechanicals)

  3. Rent for $1,500–$1,800/month

  4. Refinance to pull equity and repeat

The math works because appreciation + rent growth keep equity climbing year over year.

Curious how this compares nearby? Read How to House Hack in Fountain Square to see how investors are applying similar strategies one neighborhood over.

4. Proximity to Downtown & Fountain Square

Bates-Hendricks sits just minutes from Lucas Oil Stadium, Virginia Ave, and the Fountain Square cultural district, giving residents easy access to Indy’s core amenities.

That convenience attracts young professionals, medical workers, and creatives — tenants who value location and walkability but prefer lower rents than downtown.

5. Long-Term Growth Potential

Even after years of steady improvement, Bates-Hendricks still has room to grow.
As Fountain Square prices continue to rise, buyers are naturally migrating south — a classic spillover effect that has driven appreciation in cities nationwide.

With ongoing infrastructure upgrades and increased homeownership, investors who buy now are likely to ride another 3–5 years of steady appreciation.

Property Types You’ll Find in Bates-Hendricks

Type

Typical Price Range (2025)

Investment Potential

Historic Fixer-Uppers

$160K–$250K

Best for BRRRR or flip

Turnkey Renovations

$275K–$325K

Strong rent + low maintenance

Small Duplexes

$275K–$350K

Ideal for house hackers

New Builds (Infill)

$350K–$450K

Great appreciation, low supply

The neighborhood’s mix of property ages gives investors plenty of flexibility, whether you want to flip, hold, or rent long-term.

Market Snapshot: Bates-Hendricks vs. Nearby Neighborhoods

Neighborhood

Median Price (2025)

Avg Rent

Appreciation (5-Year)

Vibe

Bates-Hendricks

$295K

$1,500

+43%

Up-and-coming fixer-upper

Fountain Square

$385K

$1,750

+38%

Trendy + artsy

Garfield Park

$265K

$1,300

+32%

Affordable + stable

Downtown Indy

$310K

$1,850

+29%

Central + modern

This makes Bates-Hendricks the value buy of the near-downtown submarkets — similar lifestyle and location, lower price per square foot.

Tips for Investing in Bates-Hendricks (2025)

  1. Walk the Blocks – Condition varies street to street. Stick to well-renovated sections near Lincoln St, East St, and Palmer Ave.

  2. Budget for Updates – Many homes are 80–100 years old; plan for roofs, HVAC, or foundations.

  3. Focus on Curb Appeal – Buyers and renters here are drawn to the “HGTV aesthetic” — clean, bright, and modern farmhouse-style finishes.

  4. Screen Tenants Carefully – Demand is strong, but good management ensures long-term returns.

  5. Hold for the Long Game – The best returns in Bates-Hendricks come from 3–7 year holds as the area continues to mature.

Investor ROI Snapshot (2025)

Metric

Range

Cap Rate

7–9%

Cash-on-Cash Return

8–10%

Appreciation Rate

4–6%

Vacancy Rate

~5%

5-Year ROI (Est.)

35–45%

These numbers put Bates-Hendricks among Indy’s top-performing neighborhoods for value-add investors.

Investor FAQs: Bates-Hendricks Real Estate

Is Bates-Hendricks still affordable in 2025?

Yes — while prices have risen, it remains far cheaper than nearby Fountain Square or downtown, with similar rental potential.

What kind of properties perform best here?

Updated single-family homes and small duplexes — both appeal to renters and resale buyers.

Can you still flip homes here profitably?

Absolutely. Low acquisition costs and high buyer demand for renovated homes make flipping viable, especially under $325K ARV.

Is Bates-Hendricks good for out-of-state investors?

Yes. Its compact size, strong rent demand, and ongoing growth make it a manageable entry point for remote investors.

Final Thoughts: Indy’s Fixer-Upper Gem with Big Potential

Bates-Hendricks has officially evolved from “underrated” to “can’t-miss.” With strong rent growth, ongoing revitalization, and close proximity to downtown, this southside neighborhood offers the perfect mix of affordability and appreciation potential.

Whether you’re flipping, BRRRRing, or house hacking, Bates-Hendricks gives investors the kind of opportunity that’s getting harder to find elsewhere in Indy.

👉 Explore Investor Resources →

Once a quiet, overlooked pocket just south of downtown, Bates-Hendricks has exploded into one of Indianapolis’s hottest small-scale investment markets.

With proximity to Fountain Square and downtown, charming historic homes, and an active neighborhood association, this area has become a go-to for BRRRR investors, flippers, and first-time buyers looking for solid returns under $350K.

Here’s why Bates-Hendricks is on every investor’s radar in 2025 — and how to make the most of this fixer-upper-friendly neighborhood.

Bates-Hendricks at a Glance (2025)

Location: Just south of downtown Indianapolis, bordered by Madison Ave, East St, and I-70
Vibe: Historic charm meets new energy
Average home price: ~$295,000 (Redfin, Q3 2025)
Average rent: $1,500/month
Appreciation (past 5 years): +43%
Vacancy rate: ~5% (below city average)

In short: Bates-Hendricks offers downtown proximity, affordable buy-ins, and tons of rehab potential — a rare combo for Indy investors in 2025.

Why Investors Love Bates-Hendricks

1. Affordable Entry + Strong ROI

Homes here are priced well below nearby Fountain Square, but rent and resale numbers are quickly catching up.

  • Entry prices: $225K–$325K for renovated homes, $160K–$220K for fixer-uppers

  • Rent potential: $1,400–$1,800/month for 2–3 bedroom homes

  • Cap rates: 7–9% for turnkey rentals, up to 10%+ for rehabbed BRRRR projects

For investors priced out of Fountain Square or downtown, Bates-Hendricks offers real cash flow with upside appreciation.

2. Ongoing Neighborhood Revitalization

The Bates-Hendricks Neighborhood Association and local developers have been steadily revitalizing the area since the early 2010s.

Recent improvements include:

  • New sidewalks, parks, and public spaces

  • Restored historic homes and duplexes

  • Local businesses like Lincoln Lane Coffee and Two Chicks District Co. (made famous by HGTV’s Good Bones)

That visibility has drawn new homeowners and investors, pushing up both home values and rent demand.

3. Perfect for BRRRR and House Hacking

Bates-Hendricks is ideal for Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat (BRRRR) investors and house hackers who want to live in one side of a duplex while renting the other.

Typical strategy:

  1. Buy a dated single-family or duplex under $250K

  2. Invest $40K–$60K in updates (kitchen, bath, mechanicals)

  3. Rent for $1,500–$1,800/month

  4. Refinance to pull equity and repeat

The math works because appreciation + rent growth keep equity climbing year over year.

Curious how this compares nearby? Read How to House Hack in Fountain Square to see how investors are applying similar strategies one neighborhood over.

4. Proximity to Downtown & Fountain Square

Bates-Hendricks sits just minutes from Lucas Oil Stadium, Virginia Ave, and the Fountain Square cultural district, giving residents easy access to Indy’s core amenities.

That convenience attracts young professionals, medical workers, and creatives — tenants who value location and walkability but prefer lower rents than downtown.

5. Long-Term Growth Potential

Even after years of steady improvement, Bates-Hendricks still has room to grow.
As Fountain Square prices continue to rise, buyers are naturally migrating south — a classic spillover effect that has driven appreciation in cities nationwide.

With ongoing infrastructure upgrades and increased homeownership, investors who buy now are likely to ride another 3–5 years of steady appreciation.

Property Types You’ll Find in Bates-Hendricks

Type

Typical Price Range (2025)

Investment Potential

Historic Fixer-Uppers

$160K–$250K

Best for BRRRR or flip

Turnkey Renovations

$275K–$325K

Strong rent + low maintenance

Small Duplexes

$275K–$350K

Ideal for house hackers

New Builds (Infill)

$350K–$450K

Great appreciation, low supply

The neighborhood’s mix of property ages gives investors plenty of flexibility, whether you want to flip, hold, or rent long-term.

Market Snapshot: Bates-Hendricks vs. Nearby Neighborhoods

Neighborhood

Median Price (2025)

Avg Rent

Appreciation (5-Year)

Vibe

Bates-Hendricks

$295K

$1,500

+43%

Up-and-coming fixer-upper

Fountain Square

$385K

$1,750

+38%

Trendy + artsy

Garfield Park

$265K

$1,300

+32%

Affordable + stable

Downtown Indy

$310K

$1,850

+29%

Central + modern

This makes Bates-Hendricks the value buy of the near-downtown submarkets — similar lifestyle and location, lower price per square foot.

Tips for Investing in Bates-Hendricks (2025)

  1. Walk the Blocks – Condition varies street to street. Stick to well-renovated sections near Lincoln St, East St, and Palmer Ave.

  2. Budget for Updates – Many homes are 80–100 years old; plan for roofs, HVAC, or foundations.

  3. Focus on Curb Appeal – Buyers and renters here are drawn to the “HGTV aesthetic” — clean, bright, and modern farmhouse-style finishes.

  4. Screen Tenants Carefully – Demand is strong, but good management ensures long-term returns.

  5. Hold for the Long Game – The best returns in Bates-Hendricks come from 3–7 year holds as the area continues to mature.

Investor ROI Snapshot (2025)

Metric

Range

Cap Rate

7–9%

Cash-on-Cash Return

8–10%

Appreciation Rate

4–6%

Vacancy Rate

~5%

5-Year ROI (Est.)

35–45%

These numbers put Bates-Hendricks among Indy’s top-performing neighborhoods for value-add investors.

Investor FAQs: Bates-Hendricks Real Estate

Is Bates-Hendricks still affordable in 2025?

Yes — while prices have risen, it remains far cheaper than nearby Fountain Square or downtown, with similar rental potential.

What kind of properties perform best here?

Updated single-family homes and small duplexes — both appeal to renters and resale buyers.

Can you still flip homes here profitably?

Absolutely. Low acquisition costs and high buyer demand for renovated homes make flipping viable, especially under $325K ARV.

Is Bates-Hendricks good for out-of-state investors?

Yes. Its compact size, strong rent demand, and ongoing growth make it a manageable entry point for remote investors.

Final Thoughts: Indy’s Fixer-Upper Gem with Big Potential

Bates-Hendricks has officially evolved from “underrated” to “can’t-miss.” With strong rent growth, ongoing revitalization, and close proximity to downtown, this southside neighborhood offers the perfect mix of affordability and appreciation potential.

Whether you’re flipping, BRRRRing, or house hacking, Bates-Hendricks gives investors the kind of opportunity that’s getting harder to find elsewhere in Indy.

👉 Explore Investor Resources →

Once a quiet, overlooked pocket just south of downtown, Bates-Hendricks has exploded into one of Indianapolis’s hottest small-scale investment markets.

With proximity to Fountain Square and downtown, charming historic homes, and an active neighborhood association, this area has become a go-to for BRRRR investors, flippers, and first-time buyers looking for solid returns under $350K.

Here’s why Bates-Hendricks is on every investor’s radar in 2025 — and how to make the most of this fixer-upper-friendly neighborhood.

Bates-Hendricks at a Glance (2025)

Location: Just south of downtown Indianapolis, bordered by Madison Ave, East St, and I-70
Vibe: Historic charm meets new energy
Average home price: ~$295,000 (Redfin, Q3 2025)
Average rent: $1,500/month
Appreciation (past 5 years): +43%
Vacancy rate: ~5% (below city average)

In short: Bates-Hendricks offers downtown proximity, affordable buy-ins, and tons of rehab potential — a rare combo for Indy investors in 2025.

Why Investors Love Bates-Hendricks

1. Affordable Entry + Strong ROI

Homes here are priced well below nearby Fountain Square, but rent and resale numbers are quickly catching up.

  • Entry prices: $225K–$325K for renovated homes, $160K–$220K for fixer-uppers

  • Rent potential: $1,400–$1,800/month for 2–3 bedroom homes

  • Cap rates: 7–9% for turnkey rentals, up to 10%+ for rehabbed BRRRR projects

For investors priced out of Fountain Square or downtown, Bates-Hendricks offers real cash flow with upside appreciation.

2. Ongoing Neighborhood Revitalization

The Bates-Hendricks Neighborhood Association and local developers have been steadily revitalizing the area since the early 2010s.

Recent improvements include:

  • New sidewalks, parks, and public spaces

  • Restored historic homes and duplexes

  • Local businesses like Lincoln Lane Coffee and Two Chicks District Co. (made famous by HGTV’s Good Bones)

That visibility has drawn new homeowners and investors, pushing up both home values and rent demand.

3. Perfect for BRRRR and House Hacking

Bates-Hendricks is ideal for Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat (BRRRR) investors and house hackers who want to live in one side of a duplex while renting the other.

Typical strategy:

  1. Buy a dated single-family or duplex under $250K

  2. Invest $40K–$60K in updates (kitchen, bath, mechanicals)

  3. Rent for $1,500–$1,800/month

  4. Refinance to pull equity and repeat

The math works because appreciation + rent growth keep equity climbing year over year.

Curious how this compares nearby? Read How to House Hack in Fountain Square to see how investors are applying similar strategies one neighborhood over.

4. Proximity to Downtown & Fountain Square

Bates-Hendricks sits just minutes from Lucas Oil Stadium, Virginia Ave, and the Fountain Square cultural district, giving residents easy access to Indy’s core amenities.

That convenience attracts young professionals, medical workers, and creatives — tenants who value location and walkability but prefer lower rents than downtown.

5. Long-Term Growth Potential

Even after years of steady improvement, Bates-Hendricks still has room to grow.
As Fountain Square prices continue to rise, buyers are naturally migrating south — a classic spillover effect that has driven appreciation in cities nationwide.

With ongoing infrastructure upgrades and increased homeownership, investors who buy now are likely to ride another 3–5 years of steady appreciation.

Property Types You’ll Find in Bates-Hendricks

Type

Typical Price Range (2025)

Investment Potential

Historic Fixer-Uppers

$160K–$250K

Best for BRRRR or flip

Turnkey Renovations

$275K–$325K

Strong rent + low maintenance

Small Duplexes

$275K–$350K

Ideal for house hackers

New Builds (Infill)

$350K–$450K

Great appreciation, low supply

The neighborhood’s mix of property ages gives investors plenty of flexibility, whether you want to flip, hold, or rent long-term.

Market Snapshot: Bates-Hendricks vs. Nearby Neighborhoods

Neighborhood

Median Price (2025)

Avg Rent

Appreciation (5-Year)

Vibe

Bates-Hendricks

$295K

$1,500

+43%

Up-and-coming fixer-upper

Fountain Square

$385K

$1,750

+38%

Trendy + artsy

Garfield Park

$265K

$1,300

+32%

Affordable + stable

Downtown Indy

$310K

$1,850

+29%

Central + modern

This makes Bates-Hendricks the value buy of the near-downtown submarkets — similar lifestyle and location, lower price per square foot.

Tips for Investing in Bates-Hendricks (2025)

  1. Walk the Blocks – Condition varies street to street. Stick to well-renovated sections near Lincoln St, East St, and Palmer Ave.

  2. Budget for Updates – Many homes are 80–100 years old; plan for roofs, HVAC, or foundations.

  3. Focus on Curb Appeal – Buyers and renters here are drawn to the “HGTV aesthetic” — clean, bright, and modern farmhouse-style finishes.

  4. Screen Tenants Carefully – Demand is strong, but good management ensures long-term returns.

  5. Hold for the Long Game – The best returns in Bates-Hendricks come from 3–7 year holds as the area continues to mature.

Investor ROI Snapshot (2025)

Metric

Range

Cap Rate

7–9%

Cash-on-Cash Return

8–10%

Appreciation Rate

4–6%

Vacancy Rate

~5%

5-Year ROI (Est.)

35–45%

These numbers put Bates-Hendricks among Indy’s top-performing neighborhoods for value-add investors.

Investor FAQs: Bates-Hendricks Real Estate

Is Bates-Hendricks still affordable in 2025?

Yes — while prices have risen, it remains far cheaper than nearby Fountain Square or downtown, with similar rental potential.

What kind of properties perform best here?

Updated single-family homes and small duplexes — both appeal to renters and resale buyers.

Can you still flip homes here profitably?

Absolutely. Low acquisition costs and high buyer demand for renovated homes make flipping viable, especially under $325K ARV.

Is Bates-Hendricks good for out-of-state investors?

Yes. Its compact size, strong rent demand, and ongoing growth make it a manageable entry point for remote investors.

Final Thoughts: Indy’s Fixer-Upper Gem with Big Potential

Bates-Hendricks has officially evolved from “underrated” to “can’t-miss.” With strong rent growth, ongoing revitalization, and close proximity to downtown, this southside neighborhood offers the perfect mix of affordability and appreciation potential.

Whether you’re flipping, BRRRRing, or house hacking, Bates-Hendricks gives investors the kind of opportunity that’s getting harder to find elsewhere in Indy.

👉 Explore Investor Resources →

Once a quiet, overlooked pocket just south of downtown, Bates-Hendricks has exploded into one of Indianapolis’s hottest small-scale investment markets.

With proximity to Fountain Square and downtown, charming historic homes, and an active neighborhood association, this area has become a go-to for BRRRR investors, flippers, and first-time buyers looking for solid returns under $350K.

Here’s why Bates-Hendricks is on every investor’s radar in 2025 — and how to make the most of this fixer-upper-friendly neighborhood.

Bates-Hendricks at a Glance (2025)

Location: Just south of downtown Indianapolis, bordered by Madison Ave, East St, and I-70
Vibe: Historic charm meets new energy
Average home price: ~$295,000 (Redfin, Q3 2025)
Average rent: $1,500/month
Appreciation (past 5 years): +43%
Vacancy rate: ~5% (below city average)

In short: Bates-Hendricks offers downtown proximity, affordable buy-ins, and tons of rehab potential — a rare combo for Indy investors in 2025.

Why Investors Love Bates-Hendricks

1. Affordable Entry + Strong ROI

Homes here are priced well below nearby Fountain Square, but rent and resale numbers are quickly catching up.

  • Entry prices: $225K–$325K for renovated homes, $160K–$220K for fixer-uppers

  • Rent potential: $1,400–$1,800/month for 2–3 bedroom homes

  • Cap rates: 7–9% for turnkey rentals, up to 10%+ for rehabbed BRRRR projects

For investors priced out of Fountain Square or downtown, Bates-Hendricks offers real cash flow with upside appreciation.

2. Ongoing Neighborhood Revitalization

The Bates-Hendricks Neighborhood Association and local developers have been steadily revitalizing the area since the early 2010s.

Recent improvements include:

  • New sidewalks, parks, and public spaces

  • Restored historic homes and duplexes

  • Local businesses like Lincoln Lane Coffee and Two Chicks District Co. (made famous by HGTV’s Good Bones)

That visibility has drawn new homeowners and investors, pushing up both home values and rent demand.

3. Perfect for BRRRR and House Hacking

Bates-Hendricks is ideal for Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat (BRRRR) investors and house hackers who want to live in one side of a duplex while renting the other.

Typical strategy:

  1. Buy a dated single-family or duplex under $250K

  2. Invest $40K–$60K in updates (kitchen, bath, mechanicals)

  3. Rent for $1,500–$1,800/month

  4. Refinance to pull equity and repeat

The math works because appreciation + rent growth keep equity climbing year over year.

Curious how this compares nearby? Read How to House Hack in Fountain Square to see how investors are applying similar strategies one neighborhood over.

4. Proximity to Downtown & Fountain Square

Bates-Hendricks sits just minutes from Lucas Oil Stadium, Virginia Ave, and the Fountain Square cultural district, giving residents easy access to Indy’s core amenities.

That convenience attracts young professionals, medical workers, and creatives — tenants who value location and walkability but prefer lower rents than downtown.

5. Long-Term Growth Potential

Even after years of steady improvement, Bates-Hendricks still has room to grow.
As Fountain Square prices continue to rise, buyers are naturally migrating south — a classic spillover effect that has driven appreciation in cities nationwide.

With ongoing infrastructure upgrades and increased homeownership, investors who buy now are likely to ride another 3–5 years of steady appreciation.

Property Types You’ll Find in Bates-Hendricks

Type

Typical Price Range (2025)

Investment Potential

Historic Fixer-Uppers

$160K–$250K

Best for BRRRR or flip

Turnkey Renovations

$275K–$325K

Strong rent + low maintenance

Small Duplexes

$275K–$350K

Ideal for house hackers

New Builds (Infill)

$350K–$450K

Great appreciation, low supply

The neighborhood’s mix of property ages gives investors plenty of flexibility, whether you want to flip, hold, or rent long-term.

Market Snapshot: Bates-Hendricks vs. Nearby Neighborhoods

Neighborhood

Median Price (2025)

Avg Rent

Appreciation (5-Year)

Vibe

Bates-Hendricks

$295K

$1,500

+43%

Up-and-coming fixer-upper

Fountain Square

$385K

$1,750

+38%

Trendy + artsy

Garfield Park

$265K

$1,300

+32%

Affordable + stable

Downtown Indy

$310K

$1,850

+29%

Central + modern

This makes Bates-Hendricks the value buy of the near-downtown submarkets — similar lifestyle and location, lower price per square foot.

Tips for Investing in Bates-Hendricks (2025)

  1. Walk the Blocks – Condition varies street to street. Stick to well-renovated sections near Lincoln St, East St, and Palmer Ave.

  2. Budget for Updates – Many homes are 80–100 years old; plan for roofs, HVAC, or foundations.

  3. Focus on Curb Appeal – Buyers and renters here are drawn to the “HGTV aesthetic” — clean, bright, and modern farmhouse-style finishes.

  4. Screen Tenants Carefully – Demand is strong, but good management ensures long-term returns.

  5. Hold for the Long Game – The best returns in Bates-Hendricks come from 3–7 year holds as the area continues to mature.

Investor ROI Snapshot (2025)

Metric

Range

Cap Rate

7–9%

Cash-on-Cash Return

8–10%

Appreciation Rate

4–6%

Vacancy Rate

~5%

5-Year ROI (Est.)

35–45%

These numbers put Bates-Hendricks among Indy’s top-performing neighborhoods for value-add investors.

Investor FAQs: Bates-Hendricks Real Estate

Is Bates-Hendricks still affordable in 2025?

Yes — while prices have risen, it remains far cheaper than nearby Fountain Square or downtown, with similar rental potential.

What kind of properties perform best here?

Updated single-family homes and small duplexes — both appeal to renters and resale buyers.

Can you still flip homes here profitably?

Absolutely. Low acquisition costs and high buyer demand for renovated homes make flipping viable, especially under $325K ARV.

Is Bates-Hendricks good for out-of-state investors?

Yes. Its compact size, strong rent demand, and ongoing growth make it a manageable entry point for remote investors.

Final Thoughts: Indy’s Fixer-Upper Gem with Big Potential

Bates-Hendricks has officially evolved from “underrated” to “can’t-miss.” With strong rent growth, ongoing revitalization, and close proximity to downtown, this southside neighborhood offers the perfect mix of affordability and appreciation potential.

Whether you’re flipping, BRRRRing, or house hacking, Bates-Hendricks gives investors the kind of opportunity that’s getting harder to find elsewhere in Indy.

👉 Explore Investor Resources →

Roots Realty newsletter

Be the first to see cash-flow deals and Indy investing trends.

Free. Get updates on ROI opportunities, house hacks, and value-add plays.

Roots Realty newsletter

Be the first to see cash-flow deals and Indy investing trends.

Free. Get updates on ROI opportunities, house hacks, and value-add plays.

Roots Realty newsletter

Be the first to see cash-flow deals and Indy investing trends.

Free. Get updates on ROI opportunities, house hacks, and value-add plays.

Roots Realty newsletter

Be the first to see cash-flow deals and Indy investing trends.

Free. Get updates on ROI opportunities, house hacks, and value-add plays.

Free resources

Get our free investor tools and start building equity in Indy.

Use our calculators, download the map, and find off-market deals fast.

Free resources

Get our free investor tools and start building equity in Indy.

Use our calculators, download the map, and find off-market deals fast.

Free resources

Get our free investor tools and start building equity in Indy.

Use our calculators, download the map, and find off-market deals fast.

Free resources

Get our free investor tools and start building equity in Indy.

Use our calculators, download the map, and find off-market deals fast.